Fair Lending After Disparate Impact: Know Your Story
The mortgage industry is experiencing a seismic shift in fair lending enforcement. With the recent Executive Order "Restoring Equality of Opportunity and Meritocracy" signed in April 2025, lenders face unprecedented changes in how disparate impact theories will be evaluated and enforced.
What's Changed and Why It Matters
For decades, mortgage fair lending has operated under a clear hierarchy established by the Interagency Fair Lending Examination Procedures: overt discrimination, disparate treatment, and disparate impact. The Biden administration's Combatting Redlining Initiative resulted in significant enforcement actions against ranging from major players like Fairway Independent Mortgage Corp, down to smaller lenders like the Citadel Federal Credit Union.
Now, the Trump administration's executive order represents an abrupt sea change. The order specifically directs the Attorney General, HUD Secretary, CFPB Director, and FTC Chair to evaluate all pending proceedings that rely on disparate-impact liability theories within 45 days. The administration's position is declarative: disparate-impact liability "violates the Constitution's guarantee of equal treatment" by requiring "race-oriented policies and practices to rebalance outcomes along racial lines."
The Critical Questions Every Lender Must Answer
While overt discrimination and disparate treatment remain illegal, lenders now face new uncertainties:
- How do you proactively identify potential issues? Fair lending exams still begin with HMDA and Census data analysis. When geographic lending patterns don't match area demographics, why?
- What constitutes 'merit' in mortgage lending? Is this simply another term for sound underwriting practices, or does it signal deeper changes in how creditworthiness will be evaluated?
- How can lenders lead regardless of political winds?
Your Data is Your Defense
In this evolving landscape, lenders who understand their market position, demographic reach, and lending patterns have a significant advantage. The key is moving beyond reactive compliance to proactive market intelligence.
What do we mean by proactive market intelligence?
Proactive market intelligence is:
- Where are you lending relative to community demographics?
- How do your application and approval patterns compare to market benchmarks?
- Which products and marketing strategies effectively serve communities?
- How does your lending footprint align with fair lending best practices?
The Path Forward: Own Your Story
Successful lenders don't wait for examination findings to understand their fair lending profile. They use comprehensive market intelligence to build integrous and defensible lending strategies that serve both business objectives and community needs.
Whether disparate impact enforcement increases or decreases, the fundamental truth remains: lenders who know their data, understand their markets, and can articulate their strategy will thrive. Those who operate blind to their lending patterns risk both regulatory scrutiny and missed business opportunities.
Ready to Know Your Story?
Don't let regulatory uncertainty define your fair lending strategy. Take control with data-driven insights that reveal your true market position and lending patterns
Start Your Free Trial with Polygon Vision →
Polygon Vision bundles HMDAVision and CensusVision to give you the deep strategic insights you need to build both effective marketing strategies and robust fair lending compliance. See exactly where you stand in your markets, identify opportunities for growth, and build a proactive lending story that protects your institution.
In an uncertain regulatory environment, knowledge is both power and protection.
Ready to dive deeper? Explore how leading lenders are using market intelligence to navigate fair lending challenges. Learn more →